Connect with us

Global Affairs

Dubai: A Debt Affair

 5 min read / 

Dubai, the financial, economic and commercial cornerstone of the United Arab Emirates (U.A.E.), is known for its remarkable ambition and ability to break records – from the world’s tallest building (the Burji Khalifa), to the largest shopping center (The Dubai Mall), to the busiest airport (Dubai International), in addition to some of the world’s most complex debt restructuring operations.

Accumulated over 5 years since the global financial crisis, and compounded by the plummeting oil prices since June 2014, the total debt racked up by the Emirate now exceeds $140 billion, equivalent to about 132% of the country’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP), a percentage that deserves attention, since the maximum perceived safe debt-to-GDP ratio is 70%. The debt has amassed due to the financial obligations piled up by “government-related entities” (GREs), which are partially or totally owned by the government and used as means to implement policies and deliver special services to the population. In Dubai, the most important GRE is arguably Dubai World (DPW), traded on the Nasdaq Dubai Exchange. It is an investment company that manages and supervises a diversified business and projects portfolio with the primary aim of promoting Dubai as the world’s international business and leisure capital.

Dubai World’s debt story began in 2009, in the wake of the financial crisis, which had detrimental impacts on the real estate market, with housing prices declining by 50%. At the time, the government-controlled holding shocked global markets by asking for a standstill on the $25billion burden, which had arisen from borrowings to finance projects and investments, in addition to aving the muster to request refinancing at a time of such turmoil. It was the timely intervention of the government of the neighbouring Emirate Abu Dhabi, with the injection of $20 billion, which prevented Dubai World from collapsing. Since its debt was still not fully extinguished, in 2010 Dubai World reached a first restructuring agreement for the payment of its liabilities that, in the meanwhile, with the sale of some assets (including hotels and an industrial park), had decreased to $14.6 billion. The conglomerate agreed to pay off $4.4 billion by 2015 and $10.5 billion by 2018, but the promise did not last for long.

Last December, the government-owned holding requested a new arrangement of the debt payment, reaching a second major restructuring in only 4 years. Under the new payment framework, creditors, who signed so-called “lock-up agreements,” will receive in 2015, an early repayment of the former sum, that has declined to $2.92 billion after selling some further assets, and, by 2022, the latter sum (supposed to be paid by 2018), which still amounts to $10.5billion. In spite of another extension of the burden of the debt, creditors, most of which are banks (HSBC, RBS, Standard Chartered, Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank, Emirates NBD), will be refunded with improved terms. Dubai World indeed offered a 1% increase on the $10.9 billion portion of loan and a 0.25% increase in payment in kind interest in the latest plan, Bloomberg reports.

The new deal has been possible through the implementation by the Dubai World Tribunal, of “Decree 57,” a special law issued in the wake of the financial crisis to help government-owned enterprises to successfully handle the considerable amounts of debt built up during the meltdown. Specifically, the legislation supplies government-related entities with the possibility to secure a new arrangement of the payments due, provided that “a substantial majority” of their creditors (at least 67% in agreement). The law thus forces the disagreeing minority, which still counts for approximately 33%, to accept the deal, in a technical process known as “cramdown.”

The deal constitutes a “win-win” outcome for both parties. In fact, Dubai World will have more time to maximize earnings from the disposal of its non-core assets, whereas creditors will achieve favourable credit terms sooner than expected. The restructuring operation will play a pivotal role for Dubai on the whole as well, contributing to a significant ease of the financial pressures on the city, which keeps conducting a massive investment programme in view of the hosting of the 2020 World Expo, that analysts estimate will cost between $8 and $9 billion.

The financial-economic scenario in the Emirate is not all “sunshine and roses” though. In fact, investor sentiment towards the Middle East city has been further jeopardized after another state-owned firm, Limitless, defaulted on a $400 million payment due in 2014. In the same way as Dubai World, Limitless is trying to restructure a heavy debt load ($1.2 billion), and is seeking the support of all the creditors. The problem for Dubai is that its debt position is, as said, worsened by the fall in oil prices. Although the city does not rely on oil revenues, it is indirectly exposed to them because state-backed companies depend heavily on fees generated from corporate activity, which is, of course, directly affected by the decline in oil prices. Hence, the longer oil prices remain low the more likely are GREs to struggle to repay debts. Even though Dubai is expected to attract some 25 million visitors with the global Expo, the government of the city is believed to be borrowing astonishing amounts for the preparation of such event, aspect that would further compromise Dubai’s indebtedness.

The debt affairs of Dubai’s government and its controlled entities clearly shows a reluctance to incentivize minority creditors, and a preference for the lending support of local banks to overcome any opposition. This might be a particularly risky strategy to adopt. In fact, it might help a company in the short run by guaranteeing a relatively smooth completion of deals, but in the long run it might result in reputational hazards, particularly dangerous in view of potential future debt restructuring needs. A much more careful debt management strategy should thus be designed and executed, if Dubai is to maintain a strong backing from all of its creditors and continue making its ambitions reality.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Asia

Japan Is Behind Bitcoin’s Rise

Japan Bitcoin

Deutsche Bank released a research note saying that Japanese investors account for bitcoin’s meteoric rise.

Deutsche Bank analysts have said they believe that individual Japanese foreign-exchange (FX) traders are instead moving towards leveraged cryptocurrency trading in the search for astronomical returns. Already, Japan makes up 50% of the world’s leveraged FX trading and Nikkei recently said that 40% of cryptocurrency trading was denominated in yen throughout October and November. Evidently, the Japanese are growing tired of years of ultra-low interest rates and are turning to the blockchain to boost their savings.

Keep reading |  1 min read

Global Affairs

Breakfast Briefing: Disney Buys 21st Century Fox and Snap’s Studio

Disney Fox

Disney Buys Up Murdoch Assets

Disney has bought assets in Rupert Murdoch’s empire in a deal worth $66bn.

Editor’s Remarks: 86 year-old Rupert Murdoch is set to rapidly downsize his business holdings by selling 21st Century Fox to Disney. Before the sale goes ahead, Murdoch’s Fox News will complete its planned acquisition of the 61% Sky that the company does not already own. Once complete, Sky will join other Murdoch assets such as Hollywood studio 21st Century Fox in Disney’s expanding portfolio. Disney CEO Bob Iger has confirmed he will remain in his position until 2021 and also consider a position for James Murdoch after the acquisition is complete.

Delta Opts for Airbus

Delta Air Lines bought 100 jets from Airbus instead of its rival, Boeing.

Editor’s Remarks: In a deal worth over $12.7bn, the budget North American airline chose to back Airbus by buying a large order of its A321neo jets. The airline will take delivery of the single-aisle planes in 2020 and has retained the option to purchase a further 100 jets. Meanwhile, Boeing will be licking its wounds as it now turns elsewhere to offload its 300 brand new Max 10 737s. The deal follows another large order of Airbus planes by Delta in 2014, when the carrier purchased 50 wide-body aircraft for $14bn. The last time Delta bought a major order of Boeing planes was in 2011, when it purchased 100 737s.

Capita Crashes 14%

The troubled UK outsourcing giant plunged 14% after it announced that 2017 had been subdued.

Editor’s Remarks: Capita has plunged 68% over the last two-and-a-half years as it has suffered setback after setback relating both to the quality of it services and increasing competition for big ticket contracts. The company announced that although 2017 has been in line with expectations, contract wins have come in below expectations. The sharp fall in Capita’s share price reflects how the UK stock market is presently hyper-sensitive to even the faintest whiff of a profit warning. Capita’s collapse is a huge blow to Neil Woodford, the prominent UK fund manager, who has suffered similar falls in a number of his other large holdings since the Brexit vote.

Japan Is Behind Bitcoin’s Rise

Deutsche Bank released a research note saying that Japanese investors account for bitcoin’s meteoric rise.

Editor’s Remarks: Deutsche Bank analysts have said they believe that individual Japanese foreign-exchange (FX) traders are instead moving towards leveraged cryptocurrency trading in the search for astronomical returns. Already, Japan makes up 50% of the world’s leveraged FX trading and Nikkei recently said that 40% of cryptocurrency trading was denominated in yen throughout October and November. Evidently, the Japanese are growing tired of years of ultra-low interest rates and are turning to the blockchain to boost their savings.

Snap Opens Online Studio

The studio will enable brands to build adverts that individuals users can include in their own snaps.

Editor’s Remarks: Snapchat is adding another trick to its repertoire by allowing users to add branded animations to the existing arsenal of augmented reality lenses This is not a wholly new innovation as advertisers can already sponsor lenses, although there is a hefty minimum spend of $300,000 and a current need to work closely with Snap’s design team. However, the new studio will enable advertisers to create their own adverts, which will then need to be accepted by Snap before they are given the green light. The move is part of Snap’s wider efforts to diversify their revenue streams.

 

Keep reading |  3 min read

Asia

Japanese Startup Ispace Raises $90m

Ispace

Ispace Inc raised $90m from Japan’s largest corporates in a bid to reach orbit by 2019. 

Ispace is backed by Japan Airlines, Tokyo Broadcasting System Holdings and also government-backed Innovation Network Corp. of Japan. The company plans to sell advertising space on its spacecraft, which will then feature prominently in distributed images. However, Ispace also envisages the use of rovers that will offer a “projection mapping service”, which will essentially produce a tiny billboard on the surface of the moon. This is the latest announcement in what is rapidly shaping up to be a wider commercialisation of space exploration. Elsewhere, SpaceX and Blue Origin are developing reusable rockets, while Planetary Resources intends to mine asteroids.

Keep reading |  1 min read

Trending